Abisola SalahuThere is hardly any city in the world without some level of crime. Therefore, it should come as no surprise that the worst neighborhoods in Pensacola are those places within the city that are more run down; with the highest concentration of unsavory characters. This is true even though Pensacola, Florida is not commonly associated with crime.
Generally speaking; these are the areas where intending movers who want to enjoy the sun in Florida are told to avoid. The neighborhoods are just too rough, and the people are just too aggressive. Many of those who already find themselves here will also rather be elsewhere, and this is especially true when there are children involved.
TOP 10 WORST NEIGHBORHOODS IN PENSACOLA
1. Truman Court
Truman Court ranks as the highest-crime neighborhood in Pensacola for 2026, earning a D- safety grade from DoorProfit. Its overall crime index of 184 is 84% above the national average, with violent crime running 89% above average and property crime 91% above average.
The area has a median household income of just $20,878, and 75% of residents are renters. Larceny and theft are the most elevated concerns, with an index of 197—97% above the national average. The neighborhood is described as a “high crime area” where extra caution is recommended, especially after dark.
2. Avondale
Avondale, located just west of central Pensacola, is described by local residents as a “poor area with more homeless” and is situated close to the jail. The neighborhood has faced long-standing issues with vagrancy, drug activity, and prostitution, according to community planning documents. Residents have expressed concerns about the area’s proximity to the county jail and the concentration of social challenges.
While not a residential neighborhood in the traditional sense, the area around Avondale requires vigilance, particularly at night.
3. Goya and Brookshire Area
Local residents have identified a specific property near Goya and Brookshire as a “major drug house” with constant traffic and suspicious activity. Reports describe the back storage shed being used for different people staying overnight, with stolen property tracked to the location and weapons seen on the premises.
The area has become a focal point for drug-related activity, and residents are advised to watch their children around this location and report suspicious activity to law enforcement.
4. Myrtle Grove (Twin Oaks Subdivision / 312 N. 57th Ave.)
A specific property at 312 N. 57th Ave. in the Twin Oaks subdivision of Myrtle Grove has been the source of a prolonged neighborhood crisis. The Escambia Sheriff’s Office has been called to the property more than 60 times over two years for complaints including drugs, fires, and overdose deaths—two people died of drug overdoses at the location.
Neighbors describe piles of trash, drug parties, and people passed out in the yard. One resident called it “the worst of the worst of houses.” While the broader Myrtle Grove Northwest neighborhood earns a solid A- safety grade, this specific property has been a persistent problem.
5. Westside CRA District
The Westside Community Redevelopment Area has a median household income of just $23,551 and a poverty rate of 39.5%, far above Pensacola’s citywide rate of 14.1%. The affordability index is 51, meaning incomes are too low to qualify for mortgages.
The area has a high concentration of rental properties (59% compared to 35% nationally) and has faced issues with drug activity, prostitution, and vagrancy. The Westside has also been identified as vulnerable to gentrification and displacement, with residents facing significant economic challenges.
6. West Cervantes Street Corridor (A & Cervantes)
Community planning documents identify “cocaine corners” at A Street and Cervantes Street as a persistent concern. The Cervantes Street corridor has been flagged for drug activity, prostitution, and vagrancy, with residents calling for the removal of liquor stores at D and N Streets.
The area has been a focus of neighborhood improvement efforts, but crime and blight remain challenges. Barrancas Avenue, which intersects the Westside, has been identified as one of the most unsafe corridors for pedestrians.
7. East Hill
East Hill earns a B+ safety grade from DoorProfit, but its overall crime index of 129 is 29% above the national average and 10% higher than the Pensacola average. Assault is the most elevated concern, with an index of 153—53% above the national average.
The neighborhood has a moderate crime level, with property crime running 30% above average. While East Hill is considered “safer than most” neighborhoods in Pensacola, it still experiences elevated crime compared to the safest parts of the city.
8. Morris and Attucks Courts (Public Housing Areas)
Community planning documents identify Morris and Attucks Courts as “problem areas” within the Westside neighborhoods. These public housing developments have been associated with crime and safety challenges, and residents have expressed concerns that increases in public housing could bring “more problems.” The areas have been the focus of revitalization efforts, but crime remains a concern for residents and visitors alike.
9. The “Murder Zone” (East Side)
An anonymous neighborhood mapping project labels a section of Pensacola’s East Side as the “Murder Zone,” reflecting local perceptions of elevated violent crime in that area. While not an official designation, the label indicates that residents perceive this part of the city as having a higher concentration of violent incidents.
Other anonymous labels on the map include “you can smell the drugs here” and “Heroine Needles,” suggesting drug-related concerns in specific pockets of the city.
10. Barrancas Avenue Corridor
Barrancas Avenue has been cited as one of the two streets of highest priority for safety improvements in the Westside. The corridor has narrow sidewalks, wide traffic lanes, and two of the most unsafe intersections identified in the area—at W Garden Street and W Main Street. The street design poses safety concerns for both drivers and pedestrians, with crossing the street described as “tricky and dangerous.”
While this is primarily a traffic safety issue rather than a crime hotspot, the corridor has been associated with the broader challenges of the Westside area.
COMPARISON TABLE
| Rank | Neighborhood / Area | Safety Grade | Violent Crime Index | Property Crime Index | Key Concern |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Truman Court | D− | 189 — 89% above average | 191 — 91% above average | Highest reported crime rate in the city |
| 2 | Avondale | — | — | — | Homelessness; proximity to jail |
| 3 | Goya / Brookshire | — | — | — | Drug activity; stolen property; weapons |
| 4 | Myrtle Grove (312 N. 57th St.) | — | — | — | 60+ police calls; reported overdose deaths |
| 5 | Westside CRA | — | — | — | 39.5% poverty; high concentration of rental housing |
| 6 | W. Cervantes Corridor | — | — | — | Reported drug activity, prostitution and vagrancy |
| 7 | East Hill | B+ | 114 — 14% above average | 130 — 30% above average | Assault 53% above average |
| 8 | Morris / Attucks Courts | — | — | — | Reported problem areas; public-housing concerns |
| 9 | “Murder Zone” (East Side) | — | — | — | Local perception of elevated violent crime |
| 10 | Barrancas Avenue | — | — | — | Unsafe intersections and pedestrian safety concerns |
TIPS FOR UNDERSTANDING PENSACOLA’S SAFETY LANDSCAPE
Check Official Crime Data: Pensacola’s crime varies dramatically block by block. Use DoorProfit and CrimeGrade to check specific addresses. Crime indices use 100 as the national average—a score of 184 means 84% more crime than average. Always check block-level data before committing to a neighborhood.
Pensacola is Generally Safe: The city’s overall crime rate is 17.52 per 1,000 residents, lower than the national average. Pensacola sits in the 72nd percentile for overall safety, ahead of 72% of US cities. The northwest part of the city is generally considered the safest, with victimization odds of 1 in 113, compared to 1 in 20 in the south neighborhoods.
Property Crime is More Prevalent: Across most neighborhoods, property crime—especially larceny, theft, and burglary—is more common than violent crime. Even in the highest-crime areas, the most elevated concerns are typically theft-related rather than violent offenses.
Specific Streets Can Be Hotspots: A single problem property can destabilize an entire neighborhood. The situation at 312 N. 57th Ave. in Myrtle Grove—where police were called 60+ times and two people died of overdoses—shows how one badly managed property can create a “waking nightmare” for neighbors. Checking specific addresses is essential.
Safest Areas: For those seeking the safest neighborhoods in Pensacola, consider the northwest part of the city, Cordova Park, Fox Run/Woodrun, and Myrtle Grove Northwest, which all have low reported crime and high safety scores.
Related:
Closing
Pensacola’s most challenged neighborhoods are concentrated in the Westside and select pockets of the city where poverty, disinvestment, and specific problem properties create conditions for elevated crime. Truman Court ranks as the highest-crime neighborhood with a D- safety grade and crime rates 84% above the national average.
Specific properties in Myrtle Grove and the Goya/Brookshire area have become focal points for drug activity and neighborhood distress, requiring sustained intervention from law enforcement and code enforcement. The Westside CRA district faces deep-rooted economic challenges, with 39.5% of households living below the poverty line and an affordability index of just 51.
However, it’s important to recognize that Pensacola overall is a safe city with a crime rate lower than both state and national averages, and many neighborhoods—particularly in the northwest—offer secure, family-friendly environments. By checking block-level crime data and being aware of the specific hotspots identified, residents and visitors can navigate Pensacola safely and make informed decisions about where to live.